Be Well.
David
© 2012 by Gary Vey
WARNING!
Scientific experiments have proven that if you read the following story,
you will likely be changed. Your ideas about religion, politics -- yes,
even your appreciation of art and beauty will be changed... at least
temporarily. So if you like the way you feel about life right now, maybe
you should skip this article.
I'm going to tell you something that you already know. It's something
obvious. But it's also so horrific and terrible that it must quickly be
forgotten or it could literally drive you insane. Just the reminder of
this fact will be enough to change your behavior, your outlook on the
world and the look on your face [1].
"The all encompassing blackness..." --William James 1910
I'm going to describe the cutting-edge of psychological theories, called
Terror Management Theory or TMT. It's been known for a while but has
been kept off the radar by the media. And that's partially because TMT
has been used against us (you will see how). It's a theory that explains
human behavior and its most basic psychological motivator. "In the day that you eat from it you shall surely die."
--Genesis 2:17
Are YOU afraid to die?
Terror Management Theory (TMT) states that all human behavior is
motivated by the fear of our own mortality. The fact that you and I will
eventually die and be "no more" is a fact known and understood only by
humans. Although animals have an avoidance of death, they live in the
present. They don't comprehend their destiny. Only humans have the
capacity to project reality in time and imagine the future. Only humans
realize the significance of being "no more".
The theory originated with anthropologist Ernest Becker's 1973 Pulitzer Prize-winning work of nonfiction, The Denial of Death, in which Becker argues:
All human action is taken to ignore or avoid the anxiety generated by the inevitability of death.
The terror associated with our unstoppable annihilation creates a subconscious conflict or anxiety called cognitive dissonance.
We try to cope with having to accept two contrary ideas. On one hand,
we want to become involved with life and think of ourselves as a
meaningful part of the world. On the other hand, what does anything
matter anyway if we ultimately become "no more" -- if all this
wonderment of life is temporary?
If this is all temporary, what does it matter?
According to Becker, people spend their entire lives trying to make
sense of these conflicting thoughts. We are so afraid of death that we
create alternate realities -- realities where we won't "cease to be". We
take comfort in the fact that others share this alternate reality.
Often symbols are used to reinforce our confidence in what psychologists call our worldview.
Reminders of death: Mortality Salience
Psychologists speak of an event which stimulates awareness of our own death as mortality salience.
Scientists are often curious how these reminders of death can change
our thinking and behavior. They have done many experiments on this.
Mortality salience is usually achieved in experiments by inserting
questions about such things as the subjects death plans (last Will &
Testament or Life Insurance beneficiaries) or how old his grandfather
was when he died. Half of the experimental subjects get the mortality
salience and half get benign questions, then they measure the
difference. Other times they flash the word DEATH at one twenty-forth of
a second on a screen -- so fast that the subjects cannot see it even
when they're told it is there. Yet, somehow it works. Their behavior
changes.
The basis of human culture!
TMT psychologists view human culture as a belief system constructed to
explain and give meaning to life and resist confronting the horror of
death. One of the requirements of a successful culture is to substitute
the reality of existential death with an achievable afterlife (i.e.
belief in heaven or reincarnation). If not literally, then symbolically.
Cemetery stones and burial monuments are examples of this. Cultures
also reward enduring accomplishments to civilization with material
awards, namesakes and inclusions in human history (Like naming a
building or street after someone).
The worldview is the foundation of all human culture. History records that various symbols [above]
that have been used to represent different worldviews. Each one offers
its unique explanation of how we can coexist with death and attempts to
lower our death anxiety.
The following research will show that when your worldview is threatened
by another worldview, you will be so anxious that you will fight to
defend your own belief system -- in fact, this is the basis of religious
and political wars. It doesn't matter what you think consciously
either. It's such a primal reaction that it happens anyway.
TMT Is Being Used Against Us!
When the idea was first introduced to psychology, a plethora of research
was conducted with the idea of "Tell me it ain't so!" But multiple
experiments have shown that TMT is able to predict and explain most of
the behavior we both promote and experience.
TMT theorists believe that an individual will be so freaked out by being
reminded of his death, or mortality salience, that he will invest even
more belief in his worldview and resist or violently attack anything
perceived as a threat to his worldview. So how did they test this?
Two famous experiments illustrate this phenomenon.
| The Judges & the Prostitute
Research has shown that reminding subjects of their mortality encourages
negative reactions towards others whose behaviour or attitudes deviate
from the subject's cultural worldview [8]. According to TMT, these
findings result from a heightened need for faith in the cultural
worldview that is activated by reminders of one's mortality.
 But, it was argued, bad news of any kind could produce the same effect if it got the judge in a bad mood. Experimenters responded that the subjects did not report feeling any negative reaction, but they did more experiments anyway. This time they reminded one group of their death and the other group received exposure to some other worrisome concern about the future. The same results were achieved with the mortality salience as before. The group that was reminded of death charged more for bond than the group who received other worrisome ideas [9]. The interesting fact was that the group who received the worrisome ideas reported feeling negative -- not the group who were reminded of their death. [2] Thus, consistent with Terror Management Theory, mortality salience effects seem to result exclusively from thoughts of death. TMT interprets these results as the need for an individual to invest more faith and belief in their worldview when they are reminded of their mortality. Individuals will need to become more cohesive with their groups, such as religious or political affiliations. Imagine, you can be made to be conservative and conform to the status quo by being exposed to the fear of dying. Is this a good thing? Hot Sauce 
Laboratory experiments investigating aggressive behavior pose a problem.
If the aggression is directed towards a real person there is the risk
of someone being hurt or injured. Psychologists have invented numerous
means of assessing aggression in indirect ways. A group of experimenters
recently developed a new method for measuring aggression, specifically,
the amount of hot sauce administered to a target known to dislike spicy
foods [10].In this study, the experimenters induced participants to write about either their own death (suggesting mortality salience) or a control topic, presented them with a target who either disparaged their political views or did not, and gave them the opportunity to choose the amount of hot sauce the target would have to consume. As predicted by TMT, participants who were reminded of their death allocated a particularly large amount of hot sauce to their worldview-threatening target. In additional studies, the authors found that following MS induction, if the subjects were given the opportunity to verbally express a negative attitude toward the critical target, their allocation of hot sauce decreased. These results showed that if the subjects could express their negative attitudes verbally towards their politically opposite targets, they were less likely to give them extra hot sauce (i.e. reduced aggression). This suggests that verbal degredation and acts of aggression are two alternative modes of responding to MS. [11] |
Back
in 2004, an experiment was conducted to assess the effect of a subtle
reminder of death on voting intentions for the 2004 U.S. presidential
election. On the basis of Terror Management Theory it was hypothesized
that a mortality salience suggestion would increase support for
President George W. Bush (the incumbent) and decrease support for
Senator John Kerry (the challenger).
This would happen because the incumbent president represented the status
quo -- the worldview as we knew it. Kerry was a threat to this.
In late September 2004, after receiving either a death reminder or a
neutral suggestion, registered voters were asked which candidate they
intended to vote for. In accord with predictions, Senator John Kerry
received substantially more votes than George Bush in the control
condition, but Bush was favored over Kerry following a reminder of
death, suggesting that President Bush's re-election may have been
facilitated by unconscious concerns about mortality in the aftermath of
September 11, 2001, the anthrax attacks (which originated from a
government lab) and the constant manipulation of security threat levels
attributed to vaguely described "chatter" among ill-defined "enemies" of
America.[3]
Are similar fears being used to control us today? While the Iraq and
Afghanistan wars are winding down, threats of WWIII with Iran and Israel
are keeping the mortality salience going at full speed. According to
the TMT theory, this should benefit Obama's re-election, since he
represents the status quo.
Death Anxiety Fuels Conservative Ideas
Increased prejudice toward worldview violators has been measured in a
number of experiments assessing TMT. Following death reminders, anti-gay
discrimination and affective prejudice toward gay men increased
significantly. This is, according to the study, because being homosexual
is not perceived as part of the standard world view. Deviation is a
threat to the system that helps repress the knowledge of our certain
death.[7]
In studies where men were exposed to a mortality salient event, they
preferred a more earthy, domestic and ordinary looking woman over a sexy
and seductive one. [6]
Terror management research has shown that after reminders of mortality,
people show greater investment in and support for groups to which they
belong.
In one study, subjects were presented two images of persons talking
about their own race with pride. One was black and one was white. The
White person expressing pride in his race was viewed by White
participants as particularly racist relative to a Black person who gave a
similar presentation. However, after White participants were reminded
of their own mortality, they viewed the White presentation as less
racist.[5] Even though the subjects were of different ancestral
nationality, their identification with their own race was amplified by
their reminder of their own inevitable death.
 Skulls and Bones in the Whiskey
In my college years when the Vietnam war was raging, we used to all read
and collect Playboy magazine. We were young and so mostly we didn't pay
much attention to the ads -- that is until someone pointed out that all
the liquor ads seemed to have subliminal messages in them. Our favorite
hobby, well maybe not our favorite, was looking for hidden images in
the ice cubes.
Normally, ice cubes have a montage of shadows, reflections and odd
shapes. While we found occasional nude women in some of them, most
seemed to portray images more suitable for Halloween. Skulls, skeletons
and faces screaming in agony were the most common motifs.
For years I wondered why advertisers would put such horrific images in
liquor ads. How could this possibly sell whiskey or bourbon?
TMT was obviously known to these ad men. Most addictions are diversions
from the real horror -- the reality of our eventual demise. It seems
plausible that by causing readers to experience mortality salience their
death anxiety would increase to the point where... where... where did I
put that drink?
|
It's all about self-esteem
As I hinted earlier, our appreciation of beauty has two tiers. First, we
are hard-wired to be attracted to sexual partners by evolution. We can
accurately determine good genes and fertility by our concept of what
makes a beautiful person (i.e. symmetry of facial features, good
proportions, etc.). But our appreciation of other forms of beauty seems
to have origin in our preference for pattern, repetition, organization
and symbolism. These are phenomenon in our environment associated with
replication and growth -- signs of life. This appreciation of beauty --
esthetics -- results from our avoidance of entropy -- the breakdown of order which is characteristic of our own death.
Julian Jaynes, in his acclaimed work, The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind,
showed that much of what we think and do is devoid of consciousness. He
gives strong examples of how we can drive a car while thinking about
another time and place; talk and write without awareness of the complex
process going on to produce the vocabulary. Even learning does not
require consciousness -- the phenomenon of self-awareness [12]. Or,
"Being conscious of the fact that you are conscious." In fact, our
recognition and reaction to mortality salience is without our conscious
involvement.
But something feels the "ouch!" when we get a sub-conscious reminder that we are mortal.
In Jaynes' book, he credits the development of language as the
prerequisite for the "inner dialog" that creates our awareness of the
"I" and "Me". Language is made from metaphores. Each new concept or word
is "sort of like" some other word. That's how dictionaries function. So
in order to have a concept for selfhood, a previously understood "it's
sort of like..." had to be available. We needed language before we could
develop consciousness and selfhood. The concept of "self" is therefore
not that old. Jaynes suggests it has its origins about 3000 BCE.
While
it is true that there are earlier texts showing language in cuneiform,
these are mere ledgers, records of land boundaries and crop tallies.
There is no hint of self awareness until The Epic of Gilgamesh.
The Epic of Gilgamesh is among the earliest known works of literature.
Scholars believe that it originated as a series of Sumerian legends and
poems and was written just about five hundred years shy of Jaynes'
assertions. Even more telling is what the epic is all about.
The protagonist of the story, Gilgamesh king of Uruk, has a close friend
who shares adventures with him and unexpectedly dies. Gilgamesh becomes
depressed and embarks on a journey to find "eternal life" -- the
solution to death.
Ultimately the poignant words addressed to Gilgamesh in the midst of his quest foreshadow the end result: "The life that you are seeking you will never find. When the gods created man they allotted to him death, but life they retained in their own keeping." -- [13]
Death anxiety targets our self-esteem. It motivates us to keep busy and
attempt to seek "eternal life" symbolically through our actions. An
experiment which confirmed this was conducted as follows:
Death and Self-Esteem: The Experiment
The subjects were 603 soldiers who first reported on the relevance of
automobile driving to their self-esteem. Then half of them were exposed
to various reminders of death, and the remaining to a control condition.
Experimenters then tested each group in a driving simulator to assess
their risk taking. The measures were either self-reported behavioral
intentions of risky driving or driving speed in a car simulator. As
expected, the subjects who linked their self-esteem to driving and also
received death reminders took more risks in their driving than the
control group. But what was happening here?
Another experiment had half of the participants in each condition
receiving positive feedback about their quality of driving. Presumably
this would bolster their self-esteem. Findings showed that being
reminded of death led to more risky driving than the control condition
-- but only among individuals who perceived driving as relevant to their
self-esteem. Even more significant, the introduction of positive
feedback elevated self-esteem and eliminated this effect.[4]
And besides self-esteem, mortality salience has one more conscious manifestation: evil.
Evil (Death) & The Hero
If we are conscious of ourselves, we are conscious of all that we will
have to "give up" upon our death. There is tremendous anxiety over this
and some of it is relieved in symbolic conquests where the real demon is substituted with lesser foes.
Some
of this anxiety can be exhorcize in sports or games but more often the
demons are symbols of a threat to our personal and collective
self-esteem. A threat to a group that reduces our death anxiety is a
real threat. I suspect this motivated the cruelty of Roman gladiators,
the deadly ball games of the Mayans and the demonization of Hitler and
binLaden. We need enemies to reduce our own death anxiety.
Terror Management Theory is really the theory of human culture and our
many attempts to be conscious about "something else" -- anything but
our death. That "something else" is often associated with maintaining
our self-esteem. Our self-esteem improves when we receive confirmation
from other people that we are meaningful and relevant in life. This
counteracts the powerful anxiety that comes from our absolute surety
that we will someday die and our "self" will not exist. So
organizations, political parties and religions have developed to fill
our need. Each offers a means to symbolically avoid non-existence.
St. George's defeat of the dragon [right] is a strong symbol for the fight against death.
The town had a pond, as large as a lake, where a plague-bearing dragon dwelled that envenomed all the countryside. To appease the dragon, the people of Silene used to feed it two sheep every day, and when the sheep failed, they fed it their children, chosen by lottery. It happened that the lot fell on the king's daughter, who is in some versions of the story called Sabra.[8] The king, distraught with grief, told the people they could have all his gold and silver and half of his kingdom if his daughter were spared; the people refused. The daughter was sent out to the lake, decked out as a bride, to be fed to the dragon.
Saint George by chance rode past the lake. The princess, trembling, sought to send him away, but George vowed to remain. The dragon reared out of the lake while they were conversing. Saint George fortified himself with the Sign of the Cross, charged it on horseback with his lance and gave it a grievous wound. Then he called to the princess to throw him her girdle, and he put it around the dragon's neck. When she did so, the dragon followed the girl like a meek beast on a leash. [14]
Live it... or live with it
The lesson of St. George and the Dragon is that we may not be able to
defeat death, but we can tame it. We can make the most of our life and
forget about the inevitable. Death can become a quiet and subdued
creature that follows after us like a pet. Rather than triumph over
death, we can learn to coexist with it.
To recapitulate: Consciousness, the concept of "I" and "me",
evolved only recently as a result of our development of language. With
consciousness came the discovery that this "self" was mortal and would
someday be "no more."
The most basic motivator of human culture is to create alternate
realities in which we can achieve victory over the anxiety of our
recognition of eventual death. This death anxiety is repressed in normal
consciousness but is fully "awake" subconsciously. It influences our
behavior and thoughts, makes us appreciate order and affirm life. It
creates our worldview, which we share with other humans. Different
worldviews sometimes conflict, resulting in wars and aggression.
When we are consciously reminded of our mortality, we invest more belief
in our own worldview. We attempt to have victory over our environment,
our bodies and even our instincts as a means to separate ourselves from
the natural, animalistic creatures in the hope that we are something
more permanent and worthy of immortality. This drive to symbolically
overcome death is the primary driver of human culture and influences
what we like and dislike, what is beautiful and ugly, and what is good
and evil.
Notes:
[1] "Traces of Terror: Subliminal Death Primes and Facial Electromyographic Indices of Affect", Jamie Arndt, John J. B. Allen and Jeff Greenberg, Motivation and Emotion, 2001, Volume 25, Number 3, Pages 253-277 [2] Greenberg, J., Simon, L., Harmon-Jones, E., Solomon, S., Pyszczynski, T. and Lyon, D. (1995), "Testing alternative explanations for mortality salience effects: Terror management, value accessibility, or worrisome thoughts?" European Journal of Social Psychology, 25: 417-433.
[3] "Age-related differences in responses to thoughts of one's own death: Mortality salience and judgments of moral transgressions", Maxfield, Molly; Pyszczynski, Tom; Kluck, Benjamin; Cox, Cathy R.; Greenberg, Jeff; Solomon, Sheldon; Weise, David, Psychology and Aging, Vol 22(2), Jun 2007, 341-353.
[4] The impact of mortality salience on reckless driving: A test of terror management mechanisms. Ben-Ari, Orit Taubman; Florian, Victor; Mikulincer, Mario Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Vol 76(1), Jan 1999, 35-45.
[5] "The siren's call: Terror management and the threat of men's sexual attraction to women", Landau, Mark J.; Goldenberg, Jamie L.; Greenberg, Jeff; Gillath, Omri; Solomon, Sheldon; Cox, Cathy; Martens, Andy; Pyszczynski, Tom, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Vol 90(1), Jan 2006, 129-146.
[6] Sympathy for the Devil: Evidence that Reminding Whites of their Mortality Promotes More Favorable Reactions to White Racists, Jeff Greenberg, Jeff Schimel, AndyMartens, Sheldon Solomon and Tom Pyszcnyski, Motivation and Eotion, Vol. 25, No. 2, 2001
[7] Russell J. Webstera; Donald A. Sauciera, "The Effects of Death Reminders on Sex Differences in Prejudice Toward Gay Men and Lesbians", Journal of Homosexuality, Volume 58, Issue 3, 2011, Pages 402-426
[8] Greenberg, Pyszczynski, Solomon, Rosenblatt, Veeder, Kirkland and Lyon 1990; Greenberg, Simon, Pyszczynski, Solomon and Chatel 1992; Rosenblatt, Greenberg, Solomon, Pyszczynski and Lyon 1989
[9] European Journal of Social Psychology Volume 25, Issue 4, pages 417-433, July/August 1995
[10] Joel D. Lieberman, Sheldon Solomon, Jeff Greenberg, Holly A. McGregor, "Advertising Opportunities with Wiley Online Library -- A hot new way to measure aggression: Hot sauce allocation", Aggressive Behavior, Volume 25, Issue 5, pages 331-348, 1999
[11] McGregor, Holly A.; Lieberman, Joel D.; Greenberg, Jeff; Solomon, Sheldon; Arndt, Jamie; Simon, Linda; Pyszczynski, "Terror management and aggression: Evidence that mortality salience motivates aggression against worldview-threatening others," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Vol 74(3), Mar 1998, 590-605.
[12] Jaynes, Julian, "The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind" (1976), ISBN 0-395-20729-0
[13] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epic_of_Gilgamesh
[14] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saint_George_and_the_Dragon
No comments:
Post a Comment